The Case Against Fragrance by Kate Grenville
The Case Against Fragrance will make you reassess the scents you encounter in your day-to-day life. A departure from her usual fare, the idea for this book came about while Kate Grenville was touring and promoting her previous title, One Life: My Mother’s Story. Grenville’s intolerance of strong fragrances had increased over the years but she had learnt how to minimise the impact while in her own environment. Once on tour, she was propelled into a world of freshly scented hotels, and eager, perfumed readers and, consequently, her acute fragrance headaches returned.
Beginning by asking whether fragrance headaches are a documented, recognised entity (they are), Grenville then meticulously scoured and assessed the available research on the science of scent. In exploring the fragrance industry she thinks back to when perfume was something you used sparingly and occasionally, and the reasons this was the case. She then moves on through the advent of synthetic fragrances, with their significant cost-benefits to perfumers, via the now known-to-be-harmful synthetic scents that were once added to cleaning products to make them more palatable. She also scrutinises the self-regulating fragrance-testing industry. Once Grenville starts to look at the unintended consequences of fragrance ingredients decades down the track, along with other seemingly indestructible components that appear in the offspring of test subjects, my curiosity turned to concern and sometimes anger.
This insightful and frightening book has made me very aware of the scents I consciously and unconsciously use and encounter each day, and what effect they might be having not only on me but also on those I share the air with. A fragrance that makes one person feel great and puts a smile on their face could be causing unintended harm and discomfort to the person next to them. It’s certainly something to think about.
Suzanne Steinbruckner works as a bookseller at Readings St Kilda.