Echolalia by Briohny Doyle
While Briohny Doyle’s second novel Echolalia is less overtly end-of-days than her first (The Island Will Sink), it still carries a sense of desolation that speaks to Doyle’s preoccupations with domestic unrest and climate catastrophe. In the oppressive morning heat, amid piles of trash and debris, a child’s body lies still, small, and alone. Before: the signs of his mother’s obvious post-natal depression are dismissed by her family. After: she carries her shame and guilt alone, forcefully separated from her two other children. Echolalia is written like a compelling domestic thriller but acts as an unsparing indictment on the lack of support provided to women experiencing trauma, post-natal depression and psychosis. As we follow Emma through the endlessly repeating frames of her time before and time after, Doyle expertly controls the novel’s various tensions.
Emma is a fascinating tragic character, small in nature and body, made powerless by the weight of her trauma and the pressure to conform to the social standards set by her wealthy husband and his domineering family. Her abject failure as a mother makes her socially repulsive, but Doyle probes at the hypocrisy inherent in this response – that society is willing to blame the mother if she fails her child, but not to ensure that she is supported in its care.
Towards the end of the book, Emma’s daughter Clem, now an adult, exhibits a series of artworks she calls Echolalia ‘because the drawings are repetitions’. Clem explains: ‘The repeated thing is the landscape but also the violence. Each image depicts a place from which something was taken, rendering the scenes partial and scarred. The violence isn’t obvious. You can only see it by training your eye.’ Doyle may well be referring to her own work here, as Echolalia speaks to violence on an intimate, cultural and environmental level, exploring the imprint violence leaves on people and our surroundings, as much as what it takes from us. Echolalia is an accomplished, at times provocative, piece of fiction.