When retired NFL superstar Keller Williams returns to his small town to coach his old high school football team, he's surprised how much he enjoys being out of the limelight and on the field with the kids. Even more surprising is his immediate attraction to the father of one of his players-single dad Niall Harper.Problem number one: Niall Harper isn't gay.Problem number two: Keller isn't out to the world.Problem number three: Niall hates his guts. And Keller has no idea why. High school librarian Niall Harper has always done the right thing. Except be true to himself. Divorced and raising his teenaged son, Niall is dismayed to discover the new football coach is none other than his long-ago Friday night fantasy and nemesis. Not that it matters-Keller doesn't remember him. It's nothing new; Niall has always been easy to forget. Now Keller wants to be friends. And more. Niall can't deny the annoying man makes him laugh and feel things he'd only dreamed possible. But would a player like Keller be satisfied with a regular guy like him? Being together is more than complicated, but they are willing to take the risk. Niall reveals he's dating his son's coach, and Keller comes out to the team, his fans, the press, and small-town gossips. Neither is prepared for the fallout, but that doesn't stop them. It's time to throw the Hail Mary pass of a lifetime and win the game of forever. And they're ready.