Social Freedom: The Responsibility View

When is it correct to say that a person’s freedom is restricted? Can poverty constrain freedom? Can you constrain your own freedom, for instance through weakness of the will or self-deception, and are you not truly free unless you act on a rational choice? Kristjan Kristjansson offers a critical analysis of the main components of a theory of negative liberty: the nature of obstacles and constraints, the weight of obstacles and the relation of freedom to power and autonomy. Through this discussion, which examines much of the contemporary work on political freedom, he develops his own theory of negative liberty, the so-called ‘responsibility view’, which meets many of the goals of advocates of positive liberty while retaining its distinctive ‘negative’ nature. He also argues for, and implements, a method of naturalistic revision as a way of solving conceptual disputes in social philosophy.