Meg Mills is thankful she relocated to Coastal Breeze after becoming widowed two years earlier. As she makes plans to achieve her dream of owning a small bookstore, she begins doubting herself after being harassed by her late husband's stepmother. She's also confused at her strong attraction to the shy, lanky piano tuner who arrives for an appointment one day.

Todd Davis is grateful for his aunt's encouragement to move to Coastal Breeze after a painful divorce, and is soon captivated by an outgoing piano tuning client. But he's an introvert, and feels certain the pretty widow wouldn't be interested in him. When Todd is hired as the local church's choir director, he hopes this will help him get to know the attractive widow better-if he can come out of his shell.

When the cousin who bullied Todd as a youth unexpectedly arrives in Coastal Breeze, Todd must confront his greatest fear, while getting past the pain of his memories. Meg worries that her exuberant personality has driven Todd away-until she learns the truth about his past. Can two people who are polar opposites help each other and find romance in the process?