It’s Christmas time at Pine Hollow Stables, and the Pony Tails are excited about two Pony Club holiday events: the annual Starlight Ride on Christmas Eve and a special horse show to raise money for the local animal shelter. Both Corey and Jasmine have been practising hard, in hopes of being chosen to perform in a special presentation at the show. But when only Corey is selected to ride in the show, the girls’ cheerful holiday spirits sink fast. Now Corey feels embarrassed, Jasmine feels left out, and May feels stuck in the middle. Will the three friends manage to patch things up before Christmas Eve - the night of the Starlight Ride?