The Great Multinational Tax Rort: how we're all being robbed: how we're all being robbed

Martin Feil

The Great Multinational Tax Rort: how we're all being robbed: how we're all being robbed
Format
Paperback
Publisher
Scribe Publications
Country
Australia
Published
29 August 2016
Pages
256
ISBN
9781925321647

The Great Multinational Tax Rort: how we’re all being robbed: how we’re all being robbed

Martin Feil

‘Enough is enough,’ Australia’s tax commisssioner, Chris Jordan, told a Senate inquiry earlier this year. The Great Multinational Tax Rort explains what he was talking about. Multinational corporations have avoided trillions of dollars of tax over the past 25 years. Tax avoidance is legal, but its massive abuse by multinationals has had a devastating effect on governments around the world, and has placed an unbearable burden on individual taxpayers and on honest local competitors.

Multinational corporations generate profits in around 180 countries around the world. They work hard to avoid, reduce, or delay their tax obligations for as long as possible, and they generally succeed. Sometimes they pay nothing or, at best, the percentage of their multibillion-dollar incomes that they pay in tax is a lot less than the percentage an individual worker pays.

Four accounting firms - PricewaterhouseCoopers, Ernst & Young, KPMG, and Deloitte - are the global accountants and tax advisers for the multinationals. They have been paid over $500 billion in the past 25 years to prepare annual accounts and to manage the multinationals’ tax affairs. The favourite tool of the ‘Big Four’ accountancies to minimise tax for their multinational clients is transfer pricing: a complex and confusing array of methodologies and strategies that works to reduce tax or even avoid tax payments altogether.

The Great Multinational Tax Rort explains how transfer pricing developed, and describes the strategies and tactics that the Big Four global accounting firms use on behalf of their voracious clients. Written by Martin Feil, one of the few Australian independent experts on transfer pricing and profit repatriation by multinationals - a former poacher turned gamekeeper - it is a call to arms for citizens and governments to restore a fair taxation system

Review

Having spent decades working for the Australian Taxation Office, the Customs department and in private accounting firms, Martin Feil has a true insider’s insight into the murky world of multinationals and their accounting practices. This book was written before the release of the Panama papers, however Feil mentions in the preface that these documents exposed tax evasion and avoidance by wealthy individuals and his book is about the tax minimisation strategies of multinational corporations which he argues is a far greater problem.

One of the main tactics used by corporations is called ‘transfer pricing’, a mechanism that allows parent companies (who have little responsibility to pay tax anywhere as they are ‘multinational’) to overcharge their subsidiaries (who do have an obligation to pay tax in the country in which they’re operating) for goods and services in order to minimise their profits on paper and therefore reduce their tax bill. Feil calls this the ‘global multinational crisis’ (GMC) and he asserts it is having far more destructive consequences than the global financial crisis.

This is such an important topic but one that can be difficult for the lay reader to engage with. I would have liked more anecdotes, Feil’s writing comes alive when he turns to personal anecdote and I wanted more of these. I would have also liked more devil’s advocate arguments, Feil puts everything down to greed and I think many would argue that it’s more complicated than that. Having said that, the Australian focus of this book is a great help for relating to some of the more difficult economic concepts, and Feil also explores our trading history and lays out some solutions for the future. Ultimately Feil concludes that corporate tax is a social justice issue and ‘transfer pricing has become the global monster that threatens the social fabric of the entire world’. Scary stuff, but writing a book that shines a light on this hidden world is certainly a step in the right direction.


Kara Nicholson

This item is not currently in-stock. It can be ordered online and is expected to ship in 3-5 days

Our stock data is updated periodically, and availability may change throughout the day for in-demand items. Please call the relevant shop for the most current stock information. Prices are subject to change without notice.

Sign in or become a Readings Member to add this title to a wishlist.